What happened
The University of Catholic Argentina (UCA) published a report through its Social Debt Observatory questioning the official poverty figures presented by Javier Milei's government. The study asserts that the real poverty rate could be as high as 42.4%, in contrast to the 32.3% reported by INDEC. UCA criticizes the methodology used to determine official data, stating that it does not accurately reflect actual poverty levels and raises serious concerns about the updating of the Total Basic Basket, used to measure poverty.
How each media covered it
**Perfil** titled its article "La UCA contradijo los datos de la pobreza que dio Javier Milei". This outlet focuses on the discrepancy between UCA's report and the president's assertions, quoting Agustín Salvia, the Observatory's director, who states: “Well measured, poverty today is the same as before Milei took office and could end up worse in 2027.” The estimated framing by AI is 80% left, 20% center, and 0% libertarian.
**El Cronista** titled its piece "Pobreza: la UCA cuestiona el dato del Gobierno y estima una cifra más alta", emphasizing that overly optimistic data does not correspond to reality. This outlet also cites Salvia and criticizes the lack of transparency in INDEC's measurement methods. Its estimated framing is 80% left, 15% center, and 5% libertarian.
**Página/12** chose the title "Bien medida, hay igual o más pobreza que en 2023". Like the others, it critiques the figures presented by INDEC, highlighting that poverty could be higher than indicated. It quotes Salvia and shares a similar approach to the other articles. The estimated framing by AI is 75% left, 15% center, and 10% libertarian.
Where they agree and differ
All three outlets agree in criticizing INDEC's poverty figures, highlighting that UCA's report suggests that poverty is greater than what is officially quantified. They also cite Agustín Salvia, who argues that the methodology used to calculate poverty is outdated and may be underestimating the real issue.
However, there are nuances in how they approach the topic. While Perfil focuses more on the contradiction between the government’s data and UCA's study, El Cronista mentions the lack of comparability of the data and a broader context of deterioration. Página/12 presents a more focused approach on the lack of transparency of official figures and mentions the critical perspective of other research centers on the poverty situation.
Analysis written by AI from each outlet's story and its estimated framing. It may contain errors.